For cigar enthusiasts, finding the perfect smoke can be a lifelong journey. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to navigate the world of cigars. That's why we've put together this comprehensive guide to the highest rated cigars, featuring expert advice, insider knowledge, and a curated selection of the best of the best. Whether you're a seasoned aficionado or just starting out, this article will provide you with everything you need to know to elevate your cigar game.
What Makes a Cigar "Highly Rated"?
So, what sets apart the highest rated cigars from the rest? It's not just about personal preference, although that plays a significant role. When evaluating cigars, experts consider a range of factors, including the quality of the tobacco, the skill of the blender, the construction of the cigar, and the overall smoking experience. Highly rated cigars typically boast exceptional flavor profiles, impeccable construction, and a rich, smooth smoke. They're often crafted from the finest tobaccos, carefully selected and blended to create a unique and unforgettable experience.
The Top Cigar-Rating Systems
When researching the highest rated cigars, you'll likely come across various rating systems. Here are some of the most influential and respected rating systems in the industry:
Cigar Aficionado's 100-Point System: This system, developed by Cigar Aficionado magazine, is one of the most widely recognized and respected rating systems. Cigars are evaluated on a 100-point scale, with 90-94 points indicating an "outstanding" cigar and 95-100 points denoting an "extraordinary" cigar.
Cigar Journal's 5-Star System: Cigar Journal's rating system awards cigars from 1 to 5 stars, with 5 stars indicating a "masterpiece" and 1 star indicating a "novice" cigar.
Halfwheel's 100-Point System: Halfwheel, a leading online cigar publication, uses a 100-point system similar to Cigar Aficionado's. However, their ratings are often considered more nuanced and detailed.
The Highest Rated Cigar Brands
Based on expert reviews and ratings, here are some of the highest rated cigar brands in the industry:
Padrón: Known for their rich, full-bodied flavor profiles and impeccable construction, Padrón cigars are a favorite among aficionados.
Arturo Fuente: This Dominican brand is renowned for its exquisite, handcrafted cigars featuring complex flavor profiles and stunning presentation.
OpusX: With their innovative blends and stunning packaging, OpusX cigars have gained a cult following among cigar enthusiasts.
Davidoff: This Swiss brand is synonymous with luxury and sophistication, offering a range of premium cigars with refined flavor profiles.
The Highest Rated Cigar Lines
Within each brand, there are often specific lines or series that stand out from the rest. Here are some of the highest rated cigar lines:
Padrón 1964 Anniversary Series: This iconic line celebrates Padrón's 30th anniversary and features some of the brand's most beloved and highly rated cigars.
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Series: Named after the legendary author, this series showcases Fuente's mastery of blending and construction.
OpusX PerfecXion Series: This limited-edition series pushes the boundaries of cigar innovation, featuring unique blends and stunning packaging.
Davidoff Millennium Series: This flagship line from Davidoff offers a range of premium cigars with complex flavor profiles and exquisite presentation.
What to Look for When Buying a Highly Rated Cigar
When purchasing a highly rated cigar, there are several factors to consider to ensure you're getting the best possible smoking experience:
Authenticity: Make sure you're buying from an authorized dealer to avoid counterfeits.
Storage: Proper storage is crucial to maintaining the cigar's flavor and aroma. Look for humidors or retailers that store their cigars in a controlled environment.
Handling: Handle cigars with care to avoid damaging the wrapper or affecting the flavor profile.
Aging: Some highly rated cigars benefit from aging, which can mellow out the flavors and improve the overall smoking experience.
Tips for Smoking a Highly Rated Cigar
To fully appreciate the nuances of a highly rated cigar, follow these expert tips:
Choose the right cut: A precise cut can affect the flavor profile and draw of the cigar.
Light carefully: Avoid overheating the cigar, as this can cause the flavors to become bitter and unpleasant.
Smoke slowly: Savor the experience and take slow, deliberate puffs to appreciate the complexity of the flavors.
Pair wisely: Experiment with different pairings, such as whiskey or coffee, to enhance the flavors of the cigar.
In the world of cigars, the pursuit of perfection is a lifelong journey. By understanding what makes a cigar "highly rated," familiarizing yourself with top cigar brands and lines, and following expert tips for buying and smoking, you'll be well on your way to becoming a true cigar connoisseur. Remember, the highest rated cigars are not just about personal preference – they're about the art of craftsmanship, the science of blending, and the joy of sharing a exceptional smoking experience with others.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a cigar "high-rated"?
A high-rated cigar is one that has received exceptional reviews and ratings from cigar enthusiasts, critics, and experts. Factors that contribute to a cigar's rating include its flavor profile, aroma, construction, burn quality, and overall smoking experience.
How do I choose the right cigar for me?
Choosing the right cigar depends on your personal preferences, such as flavor profile, strength, and size. Consider your smoking experience level, the occasion, and the atmosphere you want to create. You can also ask for recommendations from a cigar expert or try different types to find your favorite.
What is the difference between a Cuban and non-Cuban cigar?
Cuban cigars are made from tobacco grown in Cuba and are known for their distinct flavor profile and high quality. Non-Cuban cigars, on the other hand, are made from tobacco grown in other countries, such as the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua, and Honduras. While both types can be high-quality, Cuban cigars are often considered more prestigious and expensive.
What is the best way to store my cigars?
To keep your cigars fresh and flavorful, store them in a cool, dry place with a consistent humidity level between 65-70%. Avoid storing them in direct sunlight, near heat sources, or in areas with high humidity. Use a humidor or a cigar storage box specifically designed for cigars.
How often should I humidify my cigars?
Humidify your cigars every 1-2 weeks, depending on the humidity level in your storage area. Check the humidity level regularly and adjust as needed. Over-humidification can damage your cigars, so it's essential to find the right balance.
What is the ideal humidity level for cigars?
The ideal humidity level for cigars is between 65-70%. This range allows the cigars to breathe and maintain their flavor and aroma. Anything below 60% can cause the cigars to dry out, while above 70% can lead to mold and mildew.
Can I smoke a cigar immediately after purchase?
It's recommended to let your cigars rest for at least 24 hours after purchase to allow them to acclimate to their new environment. This helps to reduce the risk of cracking or becoming brittle.
How do I light a cigar properly?
To light a cigar, use a butane lighter or a wooden match. Hold the flame to the foot of the cigar, rotating it gently to ensure an even burn. Once lit, let the cigar burn for a few seconds before taking a puff.
What is the best way to cut a cigar?
Use a cigar cutter specifically designed for cutting cigars. Place the cutter at the cap of the cigar, and gently squeeze to make a clean cut. Avoid cutting too much of the cigar, as this can cause it to unravel.
How long does a cigar last?
The duration of a cigar depends on its size, strength, and your smoking pace. Generally, a cigar can last anywhere from 30 minutes to several hours.
Can I relight a cigar?
Yes, you can relight a cigar, but it's essential to do so carefully. Make sure the cigar has gone out completely, then relight it using a butane lighter or wooden match. Avoid relighting a cigar that has been extinguished for an extended period, as this can affect its flavor and aroma.
What is the difference between a Corona and a Robusto?
A Corona is a longer, thinner cigar, typically measuring 5-6 inches in length and 42-44 ring gauge. A Robusto, on the other hand, is shorter and thicker, measuring around 4-5 inches in length and 48-50 ring gauge. The size and shape of a cigar can affect its flavor profile and smoking experience.
What is the strongest cigar?
The strength of a cigar is subjective and depends on individual tolerance. However, some of the strongest cigars are those with high nicotine levels, such as the Gurkha Ghost or the La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero.
Can I smoke a cigar indoors?
It's generally not recommended to smoke a cigar indoors, as the smoke can linger and cause discomfort for others. However, if you must smoke indoors, make sure to do so in a well-ventilated area and use an ashtray to contain the ash and smoke.
How do I dispose of cigar ash?
Dispose of cigar ash in a responsible manner by using an ashtray or a designated ash container. Avoid disposing of ash in trash cans or on the floor, as it can create a fire hazard.
Can I share a cigar with someone?
While it's technically possible to share a cigar, it's not recommended. Cigars are a personal preference, and sharing can affect the flavor and aroma of the cigar. Additionally, sharing a cigar can also raise hygiene concerns.
How do I clean my cigar accessories?
Clean your cigar accessories regularly to prevent the buildup of residue and bacteria. Use a soft cloth and mild soap to wipe down your humidor, cutter, and lighter. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive materials that can damage your accessories.
What is the best way to travel with cigars?
When traveling with cigars, use a protective case or travel humidor to keep them safe and fresh. Check with your airline or transportation provider for any specific regulations or restrictions on traveling with cigars.
Can I smoke a cigar while pregnant?
It's strongly advised against smoking cigars or any other tobacco products during pregnancy. Smoking can pose serious health risks to both the mother and the fetus.
How do I know if a cigar is fake?
Be cautious of extremely low prices, poor packaging, and inconsistencies in the cigar's appearance. Genuine cigars usually come with a certificate of authenticity, and reputable retailers will provide information about the cigar's origin and quality.
Can I return a cigar if I don't like it?
Return policies vary depending on the retailer. Check with the retailer before making a purchase to see if they offer returns or exchanges. Some retailers may have specific conditions or restrictions for returns.
How do I become a cigar aficionado?
Become a cigar aficionado by trying different types of cigars, learning about their origins and production processes, and developing your palate. Attend cigar events, join cigar communities, and seek guidance from experienced cigar enthusiasts.
What is the most expensive cigar in the world?
The most expensive cigar in the world is the Maybach 460, which can cost upwards of $1,000 per cigar. This luxurious cigar is made from the finest tobaccos and features a unique blend of flavors.
Can I grow my own cigar tobacco?
While it's possible to grow your own tobacco, it's a complex and labor-intensive process. Cigar tobacco requires specific climate and soil conditions, and the process of curing and fermenting the tobacco is crucial to its quality. It's recommended to leave tobacco cultivation to experienced farmers and focus on enjoying high-quality cigars.