Should You Take Cigars Out of Plastic in Humidor

As a cigar enthusiast, you understand the importance of storing your precious cigars in a humidor to maintain their flavor, aroma, and overall quality. However, a common question arises: should you take cigars out of their plastic wrapping when storing them in a humidor? In this article, we'll delve into the pros and cons of removing the plastic wrap and provide you with the information you need to make an informed decision.

Why Cigars Come Wrapped in Plastic

Cigars are typically wrapped in plastic or cellophane to protect them from environmental factors that can affect their quality. The plastic wrap serves as a barrier against humidity, temperature fluctuations, and contamination from external elements. It also helps to prevent the cigars from drying out or becoming damaged during transportation and storage.

The Debate: To Remove or Not to Remove

The debate surrounding whether to remove the plastic wrap from cigars before storing them in a humidor is ongoing. Some argue that removing the wrap allows the cigars to "breathe" and absorb the humidity in the humidor, while others claim that leaving the wrap on helps to maintain a consistent environment and prevents moisture from entering the cigar.

Pros of Removing the Plastic Wrap

Removing the plastic wrap from your cigars can have several benefits:

• Improved Humidification: Without the plastic wrap, the cigars can absorb the humidity in the humidor more efficiently, which can help to maintain a consistent moisture level.

• Reduced Risk of Mold: Plastic wrap can create a humid microenvironment that's conducive to mold growth. By removing the wrap, you reduce the risk of mold developing on your cigars.

• Better Flavor and Aroma: Some cigar enthusiasts believe that removing the plastic wrap allows the cigars to "breathe" and release their natural flavors and aromas more effectively.

Cons of Removing the Plastic Wrap

While removing the plastic wrap may have its benefits, there are also some potential drawbacks to consider:

• Increased Risk of Dryness: Without the protective barrier of the plastic wrap, the cigars may be more susceptible to drying out, especially if the humidor is not properly maintained.

• Exposure to Contaminants: Removing the plastic wrap exposes the cigars to potential contaminants in the humidor, such as dust, dirt, or other environmental factors.

• Potential for Damage: Without the protective wrap, the cigars may be more prone to damage from handling or movement within the humidor.

Pros of Leaving the Plastic Wrap On

Leaving the plastic wrap on your cigars can also have its advantages:

• Consistent Environment: The plastic wrap helps to maintain a consistent environment within the humidor, which can be particularly important for sensitive or fragile cigars.

• Protection from Contaminants: The wrap acts as a barrier against external contaminants, protecting the cigars from dust, dirt, and other environmental factors.

• Easier Handling: The plastic wrap can make it easier to handle and store the cigars, as it provides an extra layer of protection against damage.

Cons of Leaving the Plastic Wrap On

While leaving the plastic wrap on may have its benefits, there are also some potential drawbacks to consider:

• Restricted Humidification: The plastic wrap can restrict the flow of humidity to the cigars, which can lead to inconsistent moisture levels and affect the overall quality of the cigars.

• Increased Risk of Mold: The humid microenvironment created by the plastic wrap can increase the risk of mold growth on the cigars.

• Reduced Flavor and Aroma: Some cigar enthusiasts believe that leaving the plastic wrap on can restrict the release of natural flavors and aromas from the cigars.

Best Practices for Storing Cigars in a Humidor

Regardless of whether you choose to remove the plastic wrap or leave it on, there are some best practices to follow when storing cigars in a humidor:

• Maintain a Consistent Humidity Level: Ensure that your humidor is set to a consistent humidity level between 65-70% to maintain the optimal environment for your cigars.

• Monitor Temperature: Keep the temperature in your humidor between 65-70°F (18-21°C) to prevent fluctuations that can affect the quality of your cigars.

• Store Cigars Upright: Store your cigars upright to prevent them from coming into contact with the humidifier or other environmental factors that can affect their quality.

• Handle Cigars with Care: Handle your cigars gently and carefully to prevent damage or breakage.

In conclusion, whether to remove the plastic wrap from your cigars before storing them in a humidor is a matter of personal preference. While removing the wrap can improve humidification and reduce the risk of mold, it also increases the risk of dryness and exposure to contaminants. Leaving the wrap on can provide a consistent environment and protection from contaminants, but it may restrict humidification and increase the risk of mold. Ultimately, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons and make an informed decision based on your specific needs and preferences. By following best practices for storing cigars in a humidor, you can ensure that your cigars remain in optimal condition and provide you with a rich, satisfying smoking experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the purpose of storing cigars in plastic in the first place?

Storing cigars in plastic is a common practice to maintain humidity and prevent moisture loss. The plastic wrapper or bag helps to retain the humidity level around the cigar, which is essential for preserving its flavor, aroma, and overall quality.

Why should I consider taking cigars out of plastic in my humidor?

Removing cigars from plastic in your humidor can help to prevent moisture buildup and reduce the risk of mold growth. This is especially important if you live in a humid climate or have a humidor that's prone to excessive moisture.

What are the risks of leaving cigars in plastic in my humidor?

Leaving cigars in plastic can lead to a range of issues, including mold growth, musty flavors, and even cigar damage. The plastic can trap moisture, causing the cigars to become over-humidified and potentially ruining them.

How do I know if my humidor is too humid?

If your humidor is consistently reading above 70% relative humidity (RH), it may be too humid. You can use a hygrometer to monitor the RH level and adjust your humidor's settings accordingly.

What is the ideal humidity level for storing cigars?

The ideal humidity level for storing cigars is between 65% and 70% RH. This range allows for the optimal balance of moisture and dryness, preserving the cigar's flavor and aroma.

Can I store cigars in a humidor without plastic?

Absolutely! In fact, many cigar enthusiasts prefer to store their cigars without plastic to allow for better air circulation and humidity regulation. However, it's essential to ensure your humidor is properly calibrated and maintained.

How often should I check on my cigars in the humidor?

It's recommended to check on your cigars at least once a week to ensure they're not developing any issues. Look for signs of mold, mildew, or excessive moisture, and adjust your humidor's settings as needed.

What is the best way to remove cigars from plastic?

When removing cigars from plastic, do so gently and carefully to avoid damaging the wrapper. You can use a soft cloth or gloved hands to handle the cigars, and make sure to inspect them for any signs of damage or defects.

Should I remove all cigars from plastic at once?

No, it's not necessary to remove all cigars from plastic at once. You can start by removing a few and monitoring their condition before deciding to remove the rest.

Can I reuse the plastic bags or wrappers?

It's generally not recommended to reuse plastic bags or wrappers, as they can harbor moisture and potentially contaminate your cigars. Instead, use new, high-quality bags or wrappers specifically designed for cigar storage.

What type of humidor is best for storing cigars without plastic?

A well-ventilated, high-quality humidor with a reliable humidification system is ideal for storing cigars without plastic. Look for a humidor with a wooden or cedar interior, as these materials tend to absorb excess moisture.

How long does it take for cigars to acclimate to a new humidor?

The acclimation process can take anywhere from a few days to a few weeks, depending on the cigar's size, type, and initial humidity level. Monitor your cigars closely during this period to ensure they're adjusting well to their new environment.

Can I store cigars in a humidor with other tobacco products?

While it's technically possible to store cigars with other tobacco products, it's not recommended. Cigars have unique humidity and storage requirements, and mixing them with other products can compromise their quality.

What is the best way to handle cigars when taking them out of the humidor?

When handling cigars, use a soft cloth or gloved hands to prevent oils from your skin from transferring to the cigar. Hold the cigar by the foot or band, and avoid touching the wrapper to prevent damage.

Can I store cigars in a humidor in a basement or attic?

It's generally not recommended to store cigars in a basement or attic, as these areas tend to be prone to extreme temperature and humidity fluctuations. Instead, store your humidor in a climate-controlled area, such as a living room or office.

How often should I clean my humidor?

It's recommended to clean your humidor every 2-3 months to prevent the buildup of mold, mildew, and bacteria. Use a soft cloth and a mild cleaning solution specifically designed for humidors.

What is the best way to monitor humidity levels in my humidor?

Use a high-quality hygrometer to monitor humidity levels in your humidor. Digital hygrometers are often more accurate than analog models, and some even provide temperature readings.

Can I use a dehumidifier in my humidor?

In some cases, a dehumidifier can be useful in controlling humidity levels in your humidor. However, be cautious not to over-dry the cigars, as this can cause them to become brittle and lose their flavor.

How do I know if my cigars are too dry?

If your cigars are too dry, they may develop cracks, become brittle, or lose their flavor and aroma. Check your cigars regularly for signs of dryness, and adjust your humidor's settings accordingly.

Can I store cigars in a humidor with a strong-smelling wood?

While some woods, like cedar, can complement the flavor and aroma of cigars, strong-smelling woods can potentially transfer their flavors to the cigars. It's best to use a humidor with a neutral or cedar interior.

What is the best way to travel with cigars?

When traveling with cigars, use a high-quality travel humidor or case specifically designed for cigar storage. These cases typically have built-in humidification systems and protective padding to keep your cigars safe.

Can I store cigars in a humidor in a garage or outdoor shed?

It's not recommended to store cigars in a garage or outdoor shed, as these areas are often subject to extreme temperature and humidity fluctuations. Instead, store your humidor in a climate-controlled area.

How long can I store cigars in a humidor?

With proper storage and maintenance, cigars can be stored in a humidor for several years. However, the optimal storage time will depend on the cigar's type, size, and initial quality.

What is the best way to inspect my cigars for damage?

Regularly inspect your cigars for signs of damage, such as cracks, mold, or mildew. Use a soft cloth and gentle handling to avoid causing further damage. If you notice any issues, remove the affected cigars from the humidor and store them separately.